Uncategorized Category

If research continues to confirm that managed care cannot save money when it is applied indiscriminately across an entire population, and can only do so when it is applied to a tiny fraction of patients, that will not bode well for managed care.

  • Comments Off on Managed care should focus on the very sick, but that could mean the end of managed care

The MIPS composite score will be a meaningless number for three reasons: The attribution method will be grossly inaccurate, the risk-adjustment method will be grossly inaccurate, and the useless cost and quality scores these methods will produce will be mashed together by an arbitrary 70-30 weighting ratio.

  • Comments Off on MIPS’ ‘composite performance score’ for doctors will be worse than useless

For nearly a half century now, the holy grail of the managed care movement has been the consolidation of the nation’s insurance companies, hospitals and clinics into large “Kaiser-like” entities.

  • Comments Off on No evidence for ‘Kaiser-like entities,’ but ‘halo’ persists

MedPAC’s job is to advise Congress on how to improve Medicare. It can’t do that if it continues to promote the double standard: evidence-based medicine for doctors and faith-based health policy for MedPAC.

  • Comments Off on MedPAC chair ‘sorry’ for recommending ‘medical home’ pilots

The ACA at Age Five: What Lessons Can We Draw?

In: Uncategorized

We can’t reform the delivery system without reforming the financing system.

This excerpt from the transcript of MedPAC’s January 2015 meeting indicates MedPAC continues to guess that ACO overhead is in the range of 1 to 2 percent of expenditures and that MedPAC continues to ignore those costs in calculating total spending on ACOs participating in Medicare’s ACO programs. Later portions of the transcript indicate ACOs are saving so little money, and are therefore getting such small “shared savings” payments back from Medicare, that ACOs are losing money. But MedPAC continues to ignore that fact as well.

  • Comments Off on MedPAC continues to ignore ACO administrative costs

In a previous post, I said the CPC Initiative would fail to produce usable results because it sought to test too many vaguely defined variables at once. In this comment I level the same criticism against the MAPCP demonstration.

  • Comments Off on CMS-state-sponsored ‘medical home’ experiment is a mess

CMS’s ‘medical home’ experiment is a mess

In: Uncategorized

The Comprehensive Primary Care Initiative, like all tests of the “medical home,” attempts to assess the impact of too many vaguely defined variables at once.

  • Comments Off on CMS’s ‘medical home’ experiment is a mess

This report by Mathematica analyzes the first year of a four-year experiment being conducted in eight states by the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation, an agency established within the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) by the Affordable Care Act.

  • Comments Off on ‘Medical homes’ raise clinic costs by at least 19 percent

What’s true in medicine is true in health policy: If you don’t diagnose correctly, you can’t prescribe correctly. If you think the primary care sector needs “redesign,” you will prescribe “medical homes” and “breaking down silos” and other nostrums with labels connoting a change in structure. If, on the other hand, you conclude the proper diagnosis is too few resources, then you recommend more resources.

  • Comments Off on ‘Medical homes’ raised costs for post-Katrina Medicaid

About this blog

Physicians for a National Health Program's blog serves to facilitate communication among physicians and the public. The views presented on this blog are those of the individual authors and do not necessarily represent the views of PNHP.

News from activists

PNHP Chapters and Activists are invited to post news of their recent speaking engagements, events, Congressional visits and other activities on PNHP’s blog in the “News from Activists” section.