Summary: Last week saw the release of a tax plan to finance California’s single payer legislation, AB 1400. It was immediately attacked as a tax increase of $12,250 per family. Hey, wait, don’t premiums and cost-sharing disappear under single payer? Yes indeed! The typical family saves money. Health insurance guaranteed, with savings. And no more medical debt or bankruptcy.
ACA-11 Taxes to fund health care coverage and cost control, California Legislative Information, Jan. 5, 2022
This measure would impose … taxes at specified rates to fund comprehensive universal single-payer health care coverage … [under AB 1400]
(1) An annual excise tax … upon a qualified business … at a rate of 2.3 percent of the gross receipts … minus the first $2,000,000 in annual gross receipts.
(2) (A) A payroll tax … on every employer who pays … 50 or more resident employees … at a rate of 1.25 percent of wages or other compensation … [plus] 1 percent of wages or other compensation in excess of $49,900 per employee.
(3) (A) … a State Personal Income CalCare Tax:
- $149,509 but not over $299,508 — 0.5% of the taxable income
- $299,509 but not over $599,012 — 1% of the taxable income
- $599,013 but not over $1,299,499 — 1.5% of the taxable income
- $1,299,500 but not over $2,484,120 — 1.75% of the taxable income
- $2,484,121 and above — 2.5% of the taxable income
California Considers Doubling its Taxes, Tax Foundation, Jan. 6, 2022, by Jared Walczak
A proposed constitutional amendment (ACA 11) in California would increase taxes by $12,250 per household …
Comment:
By Jim Kahn, M.D., M.P.H. and Don McCanne, M.D.
$12,250 per household in new taxes sounds like a lot. This plan includes a 2% payroll tax, a highly progressive income tax (starting at 0.5% at $150,000), and a business excise tax.
However — bottom line — the net savings for a typical middle-class family are highly attractive.
Currently, working families pay a lot for health care:
- $5,969 annual employee premium contribution for family coverage
- $4,000 annual per household in out-of-pocket spending
That’s $10,000, which under single payer disappears. Huge savings.
Plus, employers contribute $16,253 for premiums for family coverage. That high cost keeps wages low, so if it went away (the proposed payroll tax is about 90% lower), annual wages would rise by $10,000 or more.
Thus, for a working family, we’re into net financial gain territory.
And … the actual tax increase for a middle-class family would be way less than the $12,250 average. That’s because the tax plan relies on a very progressive income tax, $750 at $150,000 and really kicking in above $1 million in annual income.
Overall, single payer reduces costs for the vast majority of families, while providing guaranteed health care.
And: no more medical debts or bankruptcy. That’s a huge boost to financial security.
Stay informed! Subscribe to the McCanne Health Justice Monitor to receive regular policy updates via email, and be sure to follow them on Twitter @HealthJustMon.
