PNHP

Shareholder Dreams or Health Justice?

Corporate stock buybacks on top of hundreds of billions in profits favored by shareholders, versus government-run universal health insurance as favored by two in three adults. It’s time to be “politely stern” in favor of health care coverage for all.

Health Insurers Gave $120 Billion To Shareholders While Denying Your Claim, The Lever, Dec. 11, 2024, by Veronica Riccobene

As rising health care costs and inadequate insurance coverage have one in three Americans saddled with medical debt, the nation’s top health insurers have dumped billions into enriching their executives and top shareholders through lucrative stock buybacks.

All in all, the country’s largest health insurers have invested over $120 billion into repurchasing their own shares since the passage of the Affordable Care Act in 2010. These include UnitedHealth Group; Cigna; Elevance Health, the parent company of Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield; and CVS Health, which acquired Aetna in 2018.

These companies, along with Kaiser Permanente, a nonprofit health care organization, control over half of the commercial market share of the U. S. Health insurance industry. Since 2010, they’ve raked in a combined $9 trillion in revenue, netting more than $371 billion in profits.

Meanwhile, one in four Americans say they’ve avoided seeking health care in the past year because of the cost. Half of all U.S. adults say they’d be unable to afford an unexpected $500 medical expense, and medical bills account for 40 percent of U.S. bankruptcies.

Major insurers have abandoned patients for shareholder enrichment, according to former health insurance executive Wendell Potter. “Health insurers corrupted the concept of managed care and turned it into something that has really been more of managing cost, but also depriving people of the care that they need,” said Potter. “There’s no other country in the world that has a system like this that enables middlemen to siphon off so much money from middle-class and working-class folks that need health care,“ he added.

Nearly two in three Americans now say they believe health care should be the government’s responsibility, according to polling organization Gallup.

Data shows buybacks soared after Congressional Republicans and the Trump administration slashed corporations’ tax burden through the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017. Proponents of the Trump tax cuts argued that corporations would reinvest their savings into research and workers – but instead, buybacks exploded. Corporate buybacks are on track to surpass $1 trillion annually by 2025.

Comment:

By Don McCanne, M.D.

Remember, this is only one game that corporations play to move our health care dollars to their own profit line. Their combined maneuvers to reduce health spending on us as they boost their own profits is what has made the health care system in the United States the most expensive and poorest-performing system of wealthy nations.

This is certainly not news to those of us who have now worked decades to try to bring us the model of health care reform that would enable everyone to have access to comprehensive health care without increasing the total health care spending in the U.S., and that model is a single payer system that would be similar to an improved version of Medicare that covered everyone. Many studies have now shown us that this is precisely the reform that we need to provide health care for everyone without creating any personal financial hardship.

The problem is that we still have too many politicians and members of the media that respond in a rote manner with phrases such as, “We can’t afford that” (we can), or “The people don’t want the government involved” (countered by numerous surveys), or “But that’s socialized medicine” (not a bad concept when it is applied to our traditional Medicare as well), or etc., etc.

The solution is that we can no longer accept any of these phrases that tend to reject the concept when we know that single payer is exactly what we need. Now, in such instances, we need to be emphatically but politely curt as we immediately reject the negative comment whenever it is brought up and replace it with politely stern corrections, with special attention to the true facts (“politely stern”: are we creating a new, more appropriate communication standard?).

Anyway, no more passive dismissals. We need to enact and implement a system that works well for all of us, and we need to do it now. We must bring an end to the decades of delay: Health Care Justice for All – NOW and FOREVER!

PEACE AND CHARITY BE WITH US.

https://healthjusticemonitor.org…

Stay informed! Subscribe to the McCanne Health Justice Monitor to receive regular policy updates via email, and be sure to follow them on Twitter @HealthJustMon.