• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

PNHP

  • Home
  • Contact PNHP
  • Join PNHP
  • Donate
  • PNHP Store
  • About PNHP
    • Mission Statement
    • Board and Staff
    • Employment opportunities at PNHP
    • Speakers Bureau
    • Local Chapters
    • Students for a National Health Program
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
  • Kitchen Table Campaign
    • Maternal Mortality
    • Mental Health Care
    • Health Care Voters Guide
    • COVID-19 Endangers Health Workers
    • COVID-19 Exacerbates Racial Inequities
    • Public Health Emergencies
    • Rural Health Care
    • Racial Health Inequities
    • Surprise Billing
  • About Single Payer
    • What is Single Payer?
      • Policy Details
      • FAQ’s
      • History of Health Reform
      • Información en Español
    • How do we pay for it?
    • Physicians’ Proposal
      • Full Proposal
      • Supplemental Materials
      • Media Coverage
    • House Bill
    • Senate Bill
  • Stop DCEs
    • ProtectMedicare.net
    • About the REACH Model
    • About Direct Contracting
    • Direct Contracting in the News
    • Medicare Protectors
    • Sign our Petition
    • Organizational Sign-On Letter
  • Take Action
    • Medical Society Resolutions
    • Recruit Colleagues
    • Schedule a Grand Rounds
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Lobby Visits
    • Organizing in Red Districts
  • Latest News
    • Sign up for e-alerts
    • Members in the news
    • Health Justice Monitor
    • Articles of Interest
    • Latest Research
    • For the Press
  • Member Resources
    • 2021 Annual Meeting
    • Newsletter
    • Slideshows
    • Materials & Handouts
    • Kitchen Table Campaign
    • COVID-19 Response
      • Why we Need Medicare for All
      • PNHP’s 8-point plan
      • New Study: Perils and Possibilities
      • Emergency COVID-19 Legislation
      • Kitchen Table Toolkit
      • Take Action on COVID-19
      • Telling your COVID-19 story
      • PNHP members in the news
    • Events Calendar
    • Webinars
    • Film Room
    • Join or Renew Your Membership

Articles of Interest

The single-payer model: a foundation for professionalism

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By Randall White, M.D.
Canadian Healthcare Network (Toronto), Oct. 8, 2014

Obtaining orthopedic services in British Columbia is harder than it needs to be. People sometimes wait for months, but successful programs to expedite access exist, such as the Osteoarthritis Service Integration System, operated by Vancouver Coastal Health. Although the government should create more such programs, such efforts are diverted in the defence of our single-payer, not-for-profit universal healthcare system from a group that hopes to break the “government monopoly” on healthcare funding in Canada.

Dr. Brian Day, founder of Vancouver’s Cambie Surgery Centre, and other commercial specialty clinics are suing B.C. to allow private funding of medical care. This would facilitate expansion of private diagnostic and surgical procedures and undermine the single-payer model. The integrity of Canada’s entire health system could be at risk.

Advocates for commercialized healthcare funding, now prohibited by the Canada Health Act, often promote a “hybrid model.” In 2012, Dr. Day wrote in a newspaper column that European countries successfully combine universal care with a public-private system, but he failed to address the different contexts of North America and Europe.

European insurance and healthcare sectors are highly regulated. For instance, in France, even supplemental health-insurance funds are not-for-profit, unlike in Canada, where supplemental insurance, now limited to pharmacueticals, dental, vision and complementary care, is offered by for-profit corporations.

Canada has extensive commercial ties to the United States, not to Europe, and were the “hybrid” advocates to prevail, U.S. insurers could invoke NAFTA to gain access to an expanding Canadian health-insurance market.

U.S. insurance companies are unlikely to submit to a European-style model in Canada, where regulation in most sectors is already more American than European because of harmonization under NAFTA.

Furthermore, these insurance companies have the resources to get what they want. In 2013 the leading U.S. health insurers reported $12.7 billion in profit on $313.7 billion in revenue (U.S. dollars). According to OpenSecrets.org, that same year health insurers spent $154 million on lobbying U.S. lawmakers.

Using their financial clout, they could quickly change the landscape in Canadian healthcare funding for not only procedural medicine but primary care, mental-health care and other specialties.

Private-insurance-inspired managed care, capitation, pre-authorizations, routine refusals of reimbursement, restrictions on hospital admissions, onerous and costly paperwork, and loss of autonomy, which plague U.S. physicians (I know because I practised there) could follow.

Investor-owned healthcare delivery goes hand-in-hand with commercial insurance, which is why private-clinic owners are so eager to eliminate the single-payer model. They can benefit handsomely from purchase by larger entities.

For instance, in 2012, the Canadian corporation Centric Health bought Vancouver’s False Creek Healthcare Centre, founded by Dr. Mark Godley, for $24 million. Of course, this is small potatoes for U.S. hospital chains, which might invoke NAFTA to gain access to private Canadian clinics and hospitals were they to grow in size and value.

The potential for fraud also looms, as witnessed In the United States. In 2007, the company PacifiCare overbilled Medicare, the U.S. healthcare program for seniors, for an estimated $423 million. B.C.’s healthcare budget, $16 billion and growing, could become a big target for corporate scammers.

As a psychiatrist, I was especially offended by the scandal in U.S. for-profit psychiatric hospitals that investigative reporter Joe Sharkey detailed in his 1994 book “Bedlam: Greed, Profiteering, and Fraud in a Mental Health System Gone Crazy.” Psychiatrists and administrators colluded to hospitalize well-insured adults and children, some of whom had minor disorders, against their will. If we veer away from our single-payer model, are we in jeopardy of creating a similar culture here?

The question for Canadian physicians is whether the guiding principle for organizing healthcare should be the public interest or the generation of profits. For me the choice is clear.

Randall White is a psychiatrist in Vancouver. This article was written expressly for CanadianHealthcareNetwork.ca, an online site associated with the publications Medical Post and Pharmacy Practice.

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles of Interest

  • The Path to Health Equity Demands a Universal System
  • Universal Healthcare Could Have Prevented More Than 300,000 U.S. COVID Deaths
  • Medicare for All Explained Podcast: Episode 79
  • Trump wanted to privatize Medicare. Biden’s letting it happen.
  • Don’t Hand Medicare to the Profiteers
  • About PNHP
    • Mission Statement
    • Board and Staff
    • Employment opportunities at PNHP
    • Speakers Bureau
    • Local Chapters
    • Students for a National Health Program
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
  • Kitchen Table Campaign
    • Maternal Mortality
    • Mental Health Care
    • Health Care Voters Guide
    • COVID-19 Endangers Health Workers
    • COVID-19 Exacerbates Racial Inequities
    • Public Health Emergencies
    • Rural Health Care
    • Racial Health Inequities
    • Surprise Billing
  • About Single Payer
    • What is Single Payer?
      • Policy Details
      • FAQ’s
      • History of Health Reform
      • Información en Español
    • How do we pay for it?
    • Physicians’ Proposal
      • Full Proposal
      • Supplemental Materials
      • Media Coverage
    • House Bill
    • Senate Bill
  • Stop DCEs
    • ProtectMedicare.net
    • About the REACH Model
    • About Direct Contracting
    • Direct Contracting in the News
    • Medicare Protectors
    • Sign our Petition
    • Organizational Sign-On Letter
  • Take Action
    • Medical Society Resolutions
    • Recruit Colleagues
    • Schedule a Grand Rounds
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Lobby Visits
    • Organizing in Red Districts
  • Latest News
    • Sign up for e-alerts
    • Members in the news
    • Health Justice Monitor
    • Articles of Interest
    • Latest Research
    • For the Press
  • Member Resources
    • 2021 Annual Meeting
    • Newsletter
    • Slideshows
    • Materials & Handouts
    • Kitchen Table Campaign
    • COVID-19 Response
      • Why we Need Medicare for All
      • PNHP’s 8-point plan
      • New Study: Perils and Possibilities
      • Emergency COVID-19 Legislation
      • Kitchen Table Toolkit
      • Take Action on COVID-19
      • Telling your COVID-19 story
      • PNHP members in the news
    • Events Calendar
    • Webinars
    • Film Room
    • Join or Renew Your Membership

Footer

  • About PNHP
    • Mission Statement
    • Board and Staff
    • Employment opportunities at PNHP
    • Speakers Bureau
    • Local Chapters
    • Students for a National Health Program
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
  • Kitchen Table Campaign
    • Maternal Mortality
    • Mental Health Care
    • Health Care Voters Guide
    • COVID-19 Endangers Health Workers
    • COVID-19 Exacerbates Racial Inequities
    • Public Health Emergencies
    • Rural Health Care
    • Racial Health Inequities
    • Surprise Billing
  • About Single Payer
    • What is Single Payer?
      • Policy Details
      • FAQ’s
      • History of Health Reform
      • Información en Español
    • How do we pay for it?
    • Physicians’ Proposal
      • Full Proposal
      • Supplemental Materials
      • Media Coverage
    • House Bill
    • Senate Bill
  • Stop DCEs
    • ProtectMedicare.net
    • About the REACH Model
    • About Direct Contracting
    • Direct Contracting in the News
    • Medicare Protectors
    • Sign our Petition
    • Organizational Sign-On Letter
  • Take Action
    • Medical Society Resolutions
    • Recruit Colleagues
    • Schedule a Grand Rounds
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Lobby Visits
    • Organizing in Red Districts
  • Latest News
    • Sign up for e-alerts
    • Members in the news
    • Health Justice Monitor
    • Articles of Interest
    • Latest Research
    • For the Press
  • Member Resources
    • 2021 Annual Meeting
    • Newsletter
    • Slideshows
    • Materials & Handouts
    • Kitchen Table Campaign
    • COVID-19 Response
      • Why we Need Medicare for All
      • PNHP’s 8-point plan
      • New Study: Perils and Possibilities
      • Emergency COVID-19 Legislation
      • Kitchen Table Toolkit
      • Take Action on COVID-19
      • Telling your COVID-19 story
      • PNHP members in the news
    • Events Calendar
    • Webinars
    • Film Room
    • Join or Renew Your Membership
©2022 Physicians for a National Health Program,