Sebelius: Single-Payer Health Care Not In Plans

Morning Edition
NPR
June 16, 2009

Interviewer: What’s been the hardest thing for you to explain?

HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius: I think that the whole idea of the public option has been difficult, in part because I think some of the opposition has described it as a potential for a draconian scenario that was never part of the discussion in the first place. So disabusing people of what is not going to happen is often difficult because there is no tangible way to do that.

Interviewer: Can you say flat out it’s just never going to be single-payer health insurance, and we’re going to try to write it, if we can, so that it won’t ever be?

Secretary Sebelius: Oh I think that’s very much the case, and, again, if you want anybody to convince people of that, talk to the single-payer proponents who are furious that the single-payer idea is not part of the discussion.

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=105442888

The proposal to provide a government-run Medicare-like program as an option for purchase within an insurance exchange of private health plans is vehemently opposed by the insurance industry, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the AMA, all Republicans, a large bloc of conservative Democrats, and many others. No amount of negotiation can resuscitate a Medicare-like option. It’s dead.

To avoid losing the support of the progressives and many of the moderates in Congress, efforts are being made to create a new private program that has distinguishing features, primarily cosmetic, that will allow them to mislabel it as a public option. The fear of opponents is that this pseudo-public option could later be transformed into a government-run program. Thus it is imperative that the design of the option would lock it up as a private sector model with no possibility of transformation. Without that assurance, the pseudo-public option will have to be eliminated during markup in order to salvage other reform policies. The opponents will never ever sign on to single-payer-in-waiting.

Those in the progressive community who abandoned single payer to support a public Medicare-like option, believing that this was the politically feasible strategy for success, simply haven’t been paying attention if they still really believe that a government-run public option can survive. They can keep on wishing, but they would be wise to back up their position by signing Sen. Bernie Sanders’ Petition to Congress:

http://sanders.senate.gov/petitions/index.cfm?uid=7fd59f2e-88e1-477a-8eaf-762a5b050809