• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

PNHP

  • Home
  • Contact PNHP
  • Join PNHP
  • Donate
  • PNHP Store
  • About PNHP
    • Mission Statement
    • Board of Directors
    • National Office Staff
    • Speakers Bureau
    • Local Chapters
    • Students for a National Health Program
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
  • About Single Payer
    • What is Single Payer?
      • Policy Details
      • FAQs
      • History of Health Reform
      • Información en EspaƱol
    • How do we pay for it?
    • Physicians’ Proposal
      • Full Proposal
      • Supplemental Materials
      • Media Coverage
    • The Medicare for All Act of 2025
  • Take Action
    • Moral Injury and Distress
    • Medical Society Resolutions
    • Recruit Colleagues
    • Schedule a Grand Rounds
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Lobby Visits
    • Organizing in Red Districts
  • Heal Medicare
    • HealMedicare.org
    • Sign our Petition
    • Take our Survey
    • Medicare Disadvantage
    • Stop REACH
  • Kitchen Table Campaign
    • Medicare Disadvantage
    • Maternal Mortality
    • Mental Health Care
    • Health Care Voters Guide
    • COVID-19 Endangers Health Workers
    • COVID-19 Exacerbates Racial Inequities
    • Public Health Emergencies
    • Rural Health Care
    • Racial Health Inequities
    • Surprise Billing
  • Latest News
    • Sign up for e-alerts
    • Medicare Advantage harms report
    • Members in the news
    • Health Justice Monitor
    • Articles of Interest
    • Latest Research
    • For the Press
  • Member Resources
    • 2024 Annual Meeting Materials
    • Member Interest Groups (MIGs)
    • Newsletter
    • Slideshows
    • Materials & Handouts
    • Kitchen Table Campaign
    • COVID-19 Response
      • Why we Need Medicare for All
      • PNHP’s 8-point plan
      • New Study: Perils and Possibilities
      • Emergency COVID-19 Legislation
      • Kitchen Table Toolkit
      • Take Action on COVID-19
      • Telling your COVID-19 story
      • PNHP members in the news
    • Events Calendar
    • Webinars
    • Film Room
    • Join or renew your membership

Latest Research

Medicare ACOs Won’t Tell How They Pay Doctors: American Journal of Public Health Study

Organizations contracting to care for millions of Medicare enrollees won't disclose whether they penalize doctors for ordering tests, referrals or other expensive care

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE, July 12, 2017

Contact: Clare Fauke, PNHP communications specialist, 312-782-6006,Ā clare@pnhp.org

WASHINGTON, D.C. – Ninety-one percent of the accountable care organizations (ACOs) that provide care to 9 million Medicare enrollees refuse to disclose their physician payment incentives, according to new researchĀ publishedĀ in theĀ American Journal of Public Health. ACOs, similar to the HMOs of the 1990s, receive adjusted per-personĀ capitation-like payments and keep a portion of savings if they reduce patients’ use of care. Critics worry that ACOs, like HMOs, might pressure their doctors to deny needed care.

The research team from Montefiore Medical Center in New York, City University of New York at Hunter College and the national consumer group Public Citizen surveyed all 426 ACOs participating in Medicare in 2015. The survey asked how each ACO paid its primary care (PCP) and specialist physicians, and whether doctors were financially penalized for ordering tests or making referrals. Despite repeated email and mail surveys directed to the ACO’s designated public contact person, only 39 ACOs (9.2 percent of all those surveyed) provided any information on their physician payment policies.

Among the few ACOs that responded, 85 percent indicated that they tied PCPs’ compensation to quality metrics. Almost half said they offered doctors incentives to reduce care, via bonuses or withholds (financial penalties) on how much care individual doctors ordered for their patients; other times, physician reimbursement was tied to the bonuses or penalties that ACOs received from Medicare.

The researchers noted that in the 1990s there was widespread concern that HMOs were denying patients needed care. This concern led the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) to survey HMOs in the 1990s regarding their financial incentives and to require that Medicare HMOs publicly disclose those incentives. However, CMS has inexcusably waived the disclosure requirement for ACOs, which started contracting with Medicare in 2011 and, like HMOs, may gain financially by denying care.

“The lack of ACO transparency means that millions of Medicare patients can’t know how their doctors are being paid. Despite this, ACOs have garnered support from policymakers,ā€ said study author Dr. Mayce Mansour, a primary care physician at Mount Sinai who was a lead author of the study and a resident at Montefiore when the study was initiated. ā€œSince polls have shown that patients are wary of incentives for under-care, we wanted to learn more about compensation incentives that may drive physician behavior and could pose a conflict of interest.”

Dr. Nathan Favini, also a lead author of the study, said, ā€œThe public’s trust is absolutely critical for any health reform effort to succeed. ACOs should learn from the backlash against HMOs, disclose how they pay their physicians and make sure their providers are not cutting back on necessary care.”

“Millions of Medicare patients now getting their care through ACOs would be anxious to know if their doctors have incentives to skimp on their care in order to do better financially,” said Dr. Sidney Wolfe, founder of and senior adviser to Public Citizen’s Health Research Group. ā€œMost patients can’t currently find out about these incentives, and CMS’ failure to mandate their disclosure is unacceptable.”

“In 1995, I was fired by U.S. Healthcare — now called Aetna — for violating a ‘gag clause’ in my contract, and revealing that the HMO offered doctors big bonuses for denying care to our patients,” reported Dr. David Himmelstein, a distinguished professor at the City University of New York at Hunter College and lecturer in medicine at Harvard who was the study’s senior author. “In response to the ensuing public outcry, Medicare banned gag clauses and required HMOs to disclose how they pay physicians. The same rules should apply to ACOs, which are essentially the modern version of HMOs.”

*****

“Accountable Care Organizations’ Payments to Physicians: Patients Should Have the Right to Know,” by Mayce Mansour, M.D., Nathan Favini, M.D., M.S., Michael A. Carome, M.D., Sidney Wolfe, M.D., Steffie Woolhandler, M.D., M.P.H., and David U. Himmelstein, M.D.Ā American Journal of Public Health.Ā  Published online July 12, 2017.Ā  A copy of the study is available to members of the media by contactingĀ clare@pnhp.org.

Disclosures: Drs. Woolhandler and Himmelstein co-founded Physicians for a National Health Program (www.pnhp.org), a nonprofit educational and research organization that supports a single-payer national health plan.

Primary Sidebar

Recent Latest Research

  • Projected Effects of Proposed Cuts in Federal Medicaid Expenditures on Medicaid Enrollment, Uninsurance, Health Care, and Health
  • Proposed changes to Medicaid, other health programs could lead to over 51,000 preventable deaths
  • Growth of Private Equity and Hospital Consolidation in Primary Care and Price Implications
  • Less Care at Higher Cost—The Medicare Advantage Paradox
  • Taking Advantage
  • About PNHP
    • Mission Statement
    • Board of Directors
    • National Office Staff
    • Speakers Bureau
    • Local Chapters
    • Students for a National Health Program
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
  • About Single Payer
    • What is Single Payer?
      • Policy Details
      • FAQs
      • History of Health Reform
      • Información en EspaƱol
    • How do we pay for it?
    • Physicians’ Proposal
      • Full Proposal
      • Supplemental Materials
      • Media Coverage
    • The Medicare for All Act of 2025
  • Take Action
    • Moral Injury and Distress
    • Medical Society Resolutions
    • Recruit Colleagues
    • Schedule a Grand Rounds
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Lobby Visits
    • Organizing in Red Districts
  • Heal Medicare
    • HealMedicare.org
    • Sign our Petition
    • Take our Survey
    • Medicare Disadvantage
    • Stop REACH
  • Kitchen Table Campaign
    • Medicare Disadvantage
    • Maternal Mortality
    • Mental Health Care
    • Health Care Voters Guide
    • COVID-19 Endangers Health Workers
    • COVID-19 Exacerbates Racial Inequities
    • Public Health Emergencies
    • Rural Health Care
    • Racial Health Inequities
    • Surprise Billing
  • Latest News
    • Sign up for e-alerts
    • Medicare Advantage harms report
    • Members in the news
    • Health Justice Monitor
    • Articles of Interest
    • Latest Research
    • For the Press
  • Member Resources
    • 2024 Annual Meeting Materials
    • Member Interest Groups (MIGs)
    • Newsletter
    • Slideshows
    • Materials & Handouts
    • Kitchen Table Campaign
    • COVID-19 Response
      • Why we Need Medicare for All
      • PNHP’s 8-point plan
      • New Study: Perils and Possibilities
      • Emergency COVID-19 Legislation
      • Kitchen Table Toolkit
      • Take Action on COVID-19
      • Telling your COVID-19 story
      • PNHP members in the news
    • Events Calendar
    • Webinars
    • Film Room
    • Join or renew your membership

Footer

  • About PNHP
    • Mission Statement
    • Board of Directors
    • National Office Staff
    • Speakers Bureau
    • Local Chapters
    • Students for a National Health Program
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
  • About Single Payer
    • What is Single Payer?
      • Policy Details
      • FAQs
      • History of Health Reform
      • Información en EspaƱol
    • How do we pay for it?
    • Physicians’ Proposal
      • Full Proposal
      • Supplemental Materials
      • Media Coverage
    • The Medicare for All Act of 2025
  • Take Action
    • Moral Injury and Distress
    • Medical Society Resolutions
    • Recruit Colleagues
    • Schedule a Grand Rounds
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Lobby Visits
    • Organizing in Red Districts
  • Heal Medicare
    • HealMedicare.org
    • Sign our Petition
    • Take our Survey
    • Medicare Disadvantage
    • Stop REACH
  • Kitchen Table Campaign
    • Medicare Disadvantage
    • Maternal Mortality
    • Mental Health Care
    • Health Care Voters Guide
    • COVID-19 Endangers Health Workers
    • COVID-19 Exacerbates Racial Inequities
    • Public Health Emergencies
    • Rural Health Care
    • Racial Health Inequities
    • Surprise Billing
  • Latest News
    • Sign up for e-alerts
    • Medicare Advantage harms report
    • Members in the news
    • Health Justice Monitor
    • Articles of Interest
    • Latest Research
    • For the Press
  • Member Resources
    • 2024 Annual Meeting Materials
    • Member Interest Groups (MIGs)
    • Newsletter
    • Slideshows
    • Materials & Handouts
    • Kitchen Table Campaign
    • COVID-19 Response
      • Why we Need Medicare for All
      • PNHP’s 8-point plan
      • New Study: Perils and Possibilities
      • Emergency COVID-19 Legislation
      • Kitchen Table Toolkit
      • Take Action on COVID-19
      • Telling your COVID-19 story
      • PNHP members in the news
    • Events Calendar
    • Webinars
    • Film Room
    • Join or renew your membership
©2025 PNHP